The oddest example I can give you on how a client chose the colour(s) for their brand identity was,
“Our kitchen is purple, it is a great colour, I really like it and my wife picked it.” Still to this day when I think about that conversation, my brain responds with only, “huh?”.
Choosing a colour (or colours) for a brand can be tricky, mainly because colour choice relies on the personal preference of the stakeholders. More it relies on the stakeholder’s ability to check their personal preferences at the door. It isn’t uncommon to run smack into the obstacle of colour as we work through a corporate identity design or redesign, especially when multiple stakeholders are involved in the selection. There are always differing opinions on colours and what they mean (to an individual).
Add to personal bias, there are various books on the market on colour theory; there are many studies on what shade of what colour elicits the best reaction in a certain situation (we’ve all heard that salesmen in blue pinstripped suits sell more); in certain industries certain colours mean specific things; in different cultures colours can be taboo (ie. in China a man wearing a green cap signifies that his wife has cheated on him); different shades of a colour can feel completely different.
This is all enough to make your head spin! Here is my advice on how to simplify the process.
If you are rebranding and you are at the point of colour selection for the new corporate identity/logo, then you should’ve already completed a series of fact finding and brain storming exercises with your agency that reveal the following:
- what the current perception of your company is internally
- what your clients think of your company
- what the personality of your company is currently
- what the desired perception of your company both externally and internally is moving forward
- the goals of your company moving forward
- the (revised) company vision
- the (revised) company mission
- a statement about the culture of your company
Going back to this information will give you an overall message as to the personality of who your company is aspiring to be and your brand and it’s colour pallette should support this. These are some very strong clues at to which colours are appropriate for your new corporate identity.
For example if words like “fun”, “playful”, “engaging” and “free spirited”, were to describe your company’s personality, it would be appropriate to consider bright, energetic colours.
i.e.

If on the other hand words like “responsible”, “reliable”, “trust worthy”, “traditional”, “grounded” were to come up, you have a completely different personality described, which requires a completely different feel.
ie.

Now whether or not you like these colours or not is not up for debate, nor should it be when you set out to select the colours for your brand. (And for the record, I am not suggesting you use colours that you can’t bare to live with either.) The required task is to choose colours that match/express how your brand personality (and overall messaging of your brand strategy) is articulated in your documentation in order to be effective moving forward.
So, in essence, yes, when picking colours I am asking you to check your personal preferences at the door, and look deeper into what your brand requires so that it can deliver everything you desire it to.